The formula
Payroll divided by 100, times the class rate, gives the manual premium for each class. Add the classes, apply the experience mod and then any schedule credits, discounts, expense constants and state fees. Rates are filed by carriers or set by state bureaus and differ by state.
How the mod is built
NCCI's experience rating compares your actual losses to expected losses for your payroll and classes. Each claim is split at a split point. The primary portion counts in full and the excess portion counts only partly. Since 2024 NCCI has used state specific split points instead of one countrywide figure. The result is that many small claims raise a mod more than one large one.
The simplified version NCCI presents is actual losses divided by expected losses. The full formula adds ballast and weighting so small employers are not swung too hard by one year.
Want this checked against your actual policies?Send your dec pages and one prime contract. A licensed agent will tell you where you are exposed. Free, no obligation.
Check my coverageWorked example: frequency versus severity (illustrative)
Assume a split point of $20,000 to keep the arithmetic simple. Your state's actual split point may differ.
- One $100,000 claim: $20,000 primary at full weight, $80,000 excess at partial weight
- Five $20,000 claims: $100,000 primary at full weight
Same total losses. The five smaller claims put five times as much into the fully weighted primary portion. That is why claim prevention and early return to work programs move the mod more than people expect.
Audit changes
- Payroll that cannot be split by class can go to the highest rated class that applies
- Uninsured subcontractor costs can be added to payroll
- Overtime treatment varies by state. Pennsylvania's state fund, for example, counts 100% of overtime wages
Ask for the audit worksheet and check it. Errors are common and can be disputed.
Sources
- NCCI, ABCs of Experience Rating
- AssuredPartners, NCCI changes to 2024 experience mod rating
- NCCI presentation to NCOIL, basics of experience rating (2020)
- Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance, contracting class codes list
- Pennsylvania State Workers' Insurance Fund, premium audits
Sources checked 2026-11-19. Laws and forms change. If a source has moved, call us and we will confirm the current rule.