TAKKEL InsuranceUnderground contractor insurance

Mismark disputes: who pays when the marks were wrong

When a line is found outside its tolerance zone, the excavator who followed the law should not be paying. Getting that result depends on proof, measured and photographed before anything is fixed.

How common locator error is

CGA's 2025 DIRT data lists facilities not marked due to locator error at 14.2% of damages, marked inaccurately at 9.2%, and not marked because the operator or contract locator never responded at 4.2%. Its special report on locating practices found that 45% of damages tied to three hour tickets were tickets initially cleared but later marked.

The tolerance zone math

Each state defines the zone differently. Pennsylvania's is 18 inches from the outside wall or edge of the line. Kansas uses 24 inches in all horizontal directions, and water and sewer operators may elect up to 60 inches. North Carolina and South Carolina measure from the centerline using half the diameter plus 24 inches. Measure from the mark to the edge of the exposed facility and photograph the tape. A Pennsylvania PUC case summary shows the point: a facility found 24 inches from the mark was outside the 18 inch zone. Check your state on the 811 lookup.

Got a bill for a line that was not marked right?Send the ticket, positive responses and photos. We will help you build the dispute file and loop in your carrier.

Request a strike review

The dispute file

  • Ticket with the work area description, start time and expiration
  • Positive response history for every operator on the ticket
  • Photos of marks and flags before work, with a scale or tape
  • Pothole records showing where you verified other lines
  • Bore log data showing the head location at the strike
  • Measurement from mark to facility edge, photographed

Where disputes go

Many states run enforcement through a board or regulator, such as Pennsylvania's PUC Damage Prevention Committee, Georgia's PSC or North Carolina's Underground Damage Prevention Review Board. A finding against the locator or operator strengthens your position on the bill. Your carrier can also pursue subrogation if it paid.

Built by people who came from utility construction

Before the next bore, know exactly what your policies will pay for.

Or call 563.321.2430. TAKKEL Insurance, LLC, De Witt, Iowa.

Call 563.321.2430Get a quote